Jonathan Blank is the new executive director for Hospice Services of Lake County and Lake Palliative Care. Photo by Karen Pavone. LAKE COUNTY, Calif. — Hospice Services of Lake County and Lake Palliative Care recently named Jonathan Blank as the agency’s executive director.
He has previously served in leadership roles with hospice and palliative care organizations for 17 years nationally and globally.
His leadership, experience and passion for hospice care will guide the organization to sustain and grow the quality end of life care for residents in Lake County.
“We welcome Jonathan to the Hospice Services and palliative care team,” shared David Flaig, chair of the Hospice Services of Lake County Board of Directors. “His background in agency operations and strategic planning, along with his compassionate character, will play a pivotal role as we continue to extend our quality services to families in need. Our board of directors engaged in a thoughtful process to fill this leadership role. We are excited Jonathan Blank accepted this position and are thrilled how he has demonstrated commitment to mission-focused leadership and building a strong care team.”
Blank joined the organization in February, coming from a similar position in an Arizona hospice organization.
“I am excited to have this opportunity to work with the team at Hospice Services of Lake County,” says Blank. “We have outstanding employees and volunteers with an unwavering patient-centered culture that effectively aligns with other health care providers throughout the county. I look forward to sustaining the high standard of care the agency is known for and growing services that will meet the ever-changing health care needs in our community.”
Hospice Services and Lake Palliative Care is a nonprofit health care organization serving Lake County residents for over 44 years.
The core of hospice service is to provide patient- and family-centered symptom management, ensuring the highest level of comfort.
Services are available for individuals with an anticipated life expectancy of 6 months or less and their caregivers wherever they call home.
Services are paid for 100% by Medicare, Medi-Cal and the Veterans Affairs. Many private health insurances also cover hospice care.
Palliative care provides symptom management and support of all kinds to individuals with chronic conditions who have Partnership as their primary insurance.
“Community members are encouraged to learn how our compassionate team can assist you and your loved ones. Sooner is better,” said Blank.
Call 707-263-6222 or visit Hospice Services at 1862 Parallel Drive, Lakeport.
Additional information is also available on Hospice Services of Lake County’s website, www.lakecountyhospice.org.
Janine Smith-Citron is director of development for Hospice Services of Lake County.
LAKE COUNTY, Calif. — An incoming storm system is expected to bring more rain plus cold temperatures and windy conditions through this week.
The National Weather Service has issued a hazardous weather outlook or Lake County, along with a freeze warning in effect until 9 a.m. Monday, a wind advisory for Monday at 8 p.m. to Tuesday at 5 a.m. and a winter weather advisory from 8 p.m. Tuesday to 5 a.m. Thursday.
“A strong storm system will impact the region Monday through Wednesday, resulting in heavy snow occurring across the interior mountains, as well as strong gusty winds developing over exposed ridges and coastal headlands,” the forecast explained. “After Wednesday, an additional period of wet weather is forecast to develop across Northwest California next weekend.”
The forecast said that Lake County’s highest ridges — primarily in the backcountry — will experience warning level snowfall amounts.
The specific Lake County forecast calls for rain beginning on Monday night and continuing through Wednesday night.
Thursday will be clear and sunny, before chances of rain return to the forecast Friday through Sunday.
The forecast expects winds with gusts of more than 20 miles per hour on Monday evening, with wind gusts of close to 40 miles per hour expected on Tuesday night.
Daytime temperatures this week and early into next week will range from a high of 50 degrees on Monday to a low of 45 degrees on Wednesday.
Conditions at night will range from the mid to high 30s, the forecast said.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.
The lake levels are rising and while it’s going to make for an amazing summer with fishing and boating, right now we are concerned about flooding in our channel. What resources are out there? What about debris like logs and docks or other floating hazards in the Lake?
Thanks!
- Falerie in Finley
Dear Falerie,
What a great set of questions! Also, you are not the only one who has asked about lake levels, flooding and debris. These are all timely topics so I will provide some details and additional resources for each one.
Firstly, let’s revisit the way Clear Lake water level is measured, using the Rumsey Gage. Daily lake level data is measured from an in-lake gauge (#11450000) operated and maintained by the United States Geological Survey (USGS). The gauge has historically been located on a pier at Lake County Vector Control District in Lakeport, but is sometimes relocated during low water, like our past drought events required the gage to be moved to another dock location at Lakeport Library park.
Figure. Flooded conditions near park benches at Clear Lake State Park, Soda Bay, Lake County, CA. March 2023. Photo: A. De Palma-Dow Figure. Lakeport 5th Street Ramp during high water level in March 2023 (8.2 Rumsey; top) compared to low waters in 2021 (-2.0 Rumsey; bottom). Photos: A. De Palma-Dow. Right away let me address the gage issue; I have received many, many emails providing me the right gage/gauge to use. Here are some gauge facts: the vernacular use of “gage” and “gauge” can be used interchangeably and both can be used as a verb or a noun. Technically, the word “gage” is a different word altogether (it means to throw down a challenge, like a knight proposing combat). But while knighthood battles are mostly extinct, the word “gage” is still maintained in the English language. The USGS has a historical affinity for the use of “gauge”, but more recently uses gage (see the graphic below and “Rumsey Gage”). According to Merriam-Webster Dictionary, considering global use, “gauge” is the preferred variant of this word and is more commonly used than “gage”. According to ESL.com, the word “gage” is becoming obsolete. Even as I type this, my spellcheck autocorrect wants to change the “gages” to “gauges”. If you ask the Lady of the Lake, life is too short to gauge your success by the amount and type of gages being counted, but don’t mind me and pick the gauge/gage that is right for you!
It makes sense that Vector Control would be good partners for a lake gauge as low and high water levels influence habitat availability for mosquitos. Also, believe it or not, before the internet, folks would call into the Vector Control District and ask for the current lake levels; now they are simply a few clicks away on your computer or smartphone!
Figure. Lake Level data for the last 4 years (Jan 2019 - March 2023). Orange line depicts the average lake level over the last 103 years. Red solid line demonstrates the flood stage at 9 ft.Rumsey (while listed in the legend, there is no estimate gauge height depicted on this graphic). Blue line is the actual recorded gauge height. Source: USGS
Data is available for other stream, lake, and reservoir gauges around the state. I suggest you explore the Sierra Nevada River Forcast Network Interactive Map. On this site, you can find different lakes or rivers with real-time gages measuring lake levels, stream height and stream flow.
Also, the Lake County Water Resources Department monitors the daily lake level and can provide that to you by phone at 707-263-2344, if you do not have access to the website.
Determining Lake Level
Clear Lake is different then every other lake, reservoir, or water body out there when it comes to the lake level measurement method. Clear Lake uses the “Rumsey Gage” unit of measurement. This measurement was established by Captain Rumsey in 1873. The measurement was derived from the natural levels of the lake as determined by the Grisby Riffle, with a range between zero and 7.56 feet Rumsey, which is the natural low and high levels of the lake. For example, the low level at “zero rumsey” is the point at which water is too low to pass the Riffle and flow down Cache Creek; it’s the “natural low” level of the lake.
Figure. Grigsby Riffle, during normal flow years this formation regulates the amount of water that can leave Clear Lake through Cache Creek. Unlike reservoirs, Clear Lake’s water level is naturally controlled by the Grigsby Riffle. The Grigsby Riffle is a naturally formed rock gravel formation at the confluence of Cache Creek and Seigler Creek; this spot can be easily observed from the Lake Street Bridge in Lower Lake. The combination of elevation, gravel accumulation, and creek bed constriction physically limits the maximum amount of water that can pass through from the lakeside downstream to the rest of Cache Creek.
The Grigsby Riffle is what ultimately limits flow, even though the Cache Creek dam, operated by the Yolo County Flood Control and Watershed Conservation District, is currently open to allow maximum flow (currently at 2,750 cubic feet per second or CFS) to pass through the structure and down Cache Creek.
Sometimes the lake can fill up faster than the water can pass through the Grigsby Riffle, even if the dam is allowing maximum flow. That is why some years Clear Lake does reach a major flood stage and low lying homes get waves right up to their windows. There is nothing that can be done when this occurs.
There is a decree that prevents Yolo County from closing the dam when Clear Lake is at risk of flooding, but the nature of the physical outflow channel restricts flow sometimes during flood conditions.
Living on Clear Lake means you learn to live with the fluctuating conditions, there is not magic plug that can be pulled when the lake is too full and there is no magic spout to turn on when the lake is too low - it’s a natural lake and we all have to learn to love and appreciate that fact, during good times and even more so, during the difficult times.
If you don’t know about Yolo County’s Water rights over Clear Lake, and why they operate and control the lake level of Clear Lake, I suggest you visit my previous column from November 2021, “Wondering about Water Rights.”
Yolo County also manages Indian Valley Reservoir, and while they are letting out maximum flow from Clear Lake through Cache Creek, they are keeping Indian Valley dam mostly closed so that reservoir can fill up to its maximum capacity.
Currently the water releases through Indian Valley dam are at a measly 11 CFS and the reservoir is only about half way full at about 175,000 acre feet. Yolo County is properly utilizing their reservoir storage while they are required to release water from Cache Creek to prevent flooding in Clear Lake.
If you want to know more about Yolo County water operations, or the water release amounts, you can visit their website here.
Figure. Lake Level gage at the North Fork Cache Creek at Indian Valley Dam. Current reservoir level is half capacity then its last full point during winter 2019. Source: https://waterdata.usgs.gov/ Flooding
Now that Clear Lake is more than full, we are hoping to only get rain in scattered, small bursts so we don’t reach a concerning flood stage on the lake. However, some low lying areas are seeing inundation, and may already be experiencing minor flooding.
As I stated above, If the lake reaches critical flood stage, there is nothing that can be done to magically make the water recede until it works its way out through the Grigsby Riffle and Cache Creek dam. Therefore, it’s up to the residents who live in low lying areas to be prepared in the event of a flood.
First, be aware of current conditions, bookmark the lake gauges on your browser, on your computers and mobile phones. Check them often as storm events occur and after, as stream flow continues to increase lake water levels even after precipitation has stopped.
Check your flood zone area on the county of Lake Flood Plain map page, but be aware that for some areas around Clear Lake, the flood zone distinctions have recently been updated, so calling the Water Resources Department, 707-263-2344 and asking the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) Coordinator about the most recent information is the best solution.
In the meantime, the best course of action to prevent loss or damage to property due to flood, is to be prepared. The county of Lake Office of Emergency Services released a series of “Flood Prep” best practice tips for being prepared against disaster during flood season.
Road closures, due to flooded conditions, can be located on Zone Haven along with information for when they are reopened and safe for travel.
Additionally, the Lake County Department of Public Works - California facebook page posted a list of locations to purchase sandbags and sand bag assembly materials. According to the Public Works Office administrator and facebook page manager, Lori Price, “Sandbag/sand locations updated as of 11:00 AM on 3/9/23. This post is pinned at the top of the page for easy access. We will try to update it as time allows.”
For more information about shelters, or emergency services, contact the Lake County Office of Emergency Services or call them at 707-263-3450.
Now is the time to help Lake County prepare and plan for natural disasters by being informed and involved in the Update to the Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan. Participation in this plan update is essential for appropriate emergency service planning and response. It’s also important for the County to acquire funds from FEMA for disaster mitigation, which can bring more resources to the County for disaster prevention.
Debris in Clear Lake
All this rain, storms, and water means that many tree branches, docks, yard furniture, and random other natural and man-made items, can now float away and become floating debris, or boating hazards, if they make it out to the open waters of the lake.
The seasonally-small team at Lake County Marine Patrol and the staff-strapped boat operators at Water Resources are working together to coordinate the towing of debris to public locations so they are not dangerous boating hazards. Once materials are towed to shore, Parks staff at Lake County and the two cities of Lakeport and Clearlake, can help to remove items and transport them to the lake county dump, or contact the owners for pickup. Some of this work is being supported by a Cannabis Tax grant.
If you see debris in the lake, or even beached detached buoys, you can report the locations to the Water Resources Department using this online “Boating Hazards Survey.” The survey takes about 1-2 minutes, and you can fill it out from your mobile phone if you are on the lake, notice the debris from shore, or later once you come off the water.
Debris does float, and crews are not on the lake 24/7 to respond to the survey, so please only report items that are landlocked, beached, grounded, or attached to something else so they don’t float away. A survey point for a floating object on the move is basically useless and those items can be called into Marine Patrol and a description and general location provided.
For property owners who live on the lake, it’s actually a requirement that docks or structures display or affix the owners address or contact information, as per County Code Chapter 23 section 6.5 (G) (H). Additionally, as part of lakebed lease agreements, it’s the owners responsibility to maintain and secure their lake structures so they don’t break loose or dislodge and float away, potentially destroying others’ property such as neighboring docks or passing boats.
Lastly, if you live on the lake, or visited the lakeshore recently, you might have noticed a bunch of dead tule stems crowding the shoreline. They look like large, round, hollow sticks. This material is rich in the nutrient nitrogen and once it decomposes along the shoreline, will help to provide nutrition for the new tules that are going to sprout up this spring.
If this material is a nuisance to you on your property, it’s okay to rake it up and dispose of it into a green waste container, or your compost bin. There is a plethora of nitrogen in the lake, and the new tule sprouts won’t be missing out, don’t worry.
However, if you don’t want to clean up the dead tule materials, they will be broken down soon by naturally-occurring bacteria and microbes, and wildlife, such as ducks and fish, will also use them for refugia and consume the algae that grows on them for snacks.
Let’s take some time to embrace and appreciate how wonderful it is that our lake is now, once again, full and vibrant. But let’s be mindful that another drought is only, perhaps, a year away.
Sincerely,
Lady of the Lake
Angela De Palma-Dow is a limnologist (limnology = study of fresh inland waters) who lives and works in Lake County. Born in Northern California, she has a Master of Science from Michigan State University. She is a Certified Lake Manager from the North American Lake Management Society, or NALMS, and she is the current president/chair of the California chapter of the Society for Freshwater Science. She can be reached at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
The Lady of the Lake would like to acknowledge and thank Wiliam Fox from the County of Lake Water Resources Department for contribution to this column.
NORTH COAST, Calif. — A virtual town hall this week will offer community members the opportunity to hear the latest on the economy and potential impacts for the North Coast.
On Wednesday, March 29, Rep. Mike Thompson (CA-04) and Moody’s Analytics Chief Economist Mark Zandi will hold a Zoom town hall to discuss the state of the economy and other top-of-mind issues facing our communities.
The town hall will take place from 6:30 to 7:30 p.m. Pacific time.
For the first half hour, Rep. Thompson will be joined by Mr. Zandi. For the remaining time, Rep. Thompson will answer questions on general topics.
All constituents of California’s Fourth Congressional District and members of the press are invited to attend.
RSVP to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. for a Zoom link or watch live on Rep. Thompson’s Facebook page.
Thompson represents California’s Fourth Congressional District, which includes all or part of Lake, Napa, Solano, Sonoma and Yolo counties.
LAKE COUNTY, Calif. — After the Lucerne Area Town Hall waited three months to have new appointments made to its membership, the district supervisor will ask his colleagues on the Board of Supervisors to make major changes to how the town hall is structured and who can participate.
The board will meet beginning at 9 a.m. Tuesday, March 28, in the board chambers on the first floor of the Lake County Courthouse, 255 N. Forbes St., Lakeport.
The meeting ID is 914 4033 2898, pass code 404471. The meeting also can be accessed via one tap mobile at +16694449171,,91440332898#,,,,*404471#.
All interested members of the public that do not have internet access or a Mediacom cable subscription are encouraged to call 669-900-6833, and enter the Zoom meeting ID and pass code information above.
At 10:30 a.m., Supervisor EJ Crandell will ask the board to consider transitioning the Lucerne Area Town Hall to the Central Region Town Hall, or CeRTH, which will change its boundaries.
“As of right now the map for the MAC known as LATH consists of solely the community growth boundary of Lucerne,” Crandell wrote in an agenda item to the board. “With the implementation of CeRTH, the boundaries will include the full zip code boundaries of Lucerne. The concept is to ensure more inclusivity and engagement from the Central Region of District 3.”
Since the start of the year, Crandell has not brought forth any new appointments to the Lucerne Area Town Hall, other than Kevin Waycik, who was reappointed on Jan. 10 but died at the end of February.
Crandell has not explained his reasons to community members or to Lake County News until putting the matter on the agenda.
Crandell and the town hall’s members have been at odds since December, when he attempted to cancel a meeting at which the group planned to speak about its concerns with a plan by the Scotts Valley Pomo tribe to turn the Lucerne Hotel into a homeless housing facility.
The town hall’s leadership moved forward with a meeting in December in which they unanimously approved a resolution condemning the project at the hotel, a project for which Crandell’s wife has publicly advocated.
Since then, the town hall has continued to meet to discuss town business, but Crandell has not participated.
In other business, in untimed items, the board will consider a letter regarding Cal Fire’s State Responsibility Area Fire Hazard Severity Zones Maps and discuss the scope of the Lake County Fish & Wildlife Advisory Committee, the needs to support the population of the Clear Lake hitch and possible direction to staff.
The full agenda follows.
CONSENT AGENDA
5.1: Appoint Supervisor Bruno Sabatier as the voting delegate for the 2023 NACo Annual Conference & Exposition to be held in Austin, Texas, July 21 through 24, 2023.
5.2: Adopt resolution approving Agreement No.23-7306-0265-RA with the USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Services for the period July 1, 2023, through June 30, 2024, for the amount of $ 127,629.36.
5.3: Approve Amendment No. 1 to the agreement between the county of Lake and Lisa Warner, MBA for support services for managed care for fiscal year 2022-23 in the amount of $40,000 and authorize the board chair to sign.
5.4: Approve Amendment No. 1 to the agreement between Davis Guest Home and Lake County Behavioral Health Services increasing the total compensation payable under the agreement to $310,000 for FY 2022-23 and authorize the board chair to sign.
5.5: Approve lease agreement between county of Lake and Berg Investments LP for lease of the commercial space at 13300 East Highway 20, Clearlake Oaks beginning March 1, 2023, through Feb. 29, 2028, and authorize the Behavioral Health director or their designee to sign.
5.6: ERRATUM — Approve Board of Supervisors minutes from March 7, 2023, and March 14, 2023.
5.7: Adopt resolution adopting a continuous record retention and destruction schedule for the Office of the Registrar of Voters.
5.8: Adopt proclamation of appreciation for Registrar of Voters Staff, poll workers, and county key staff on successfully conducting the June and November 2022 Elections.
5.9: Approve lease for commercial property located at 858 Lakeport Blvd., Lakeport, from Feb. 1, 2023, through Feb. 28, 2024, and authorize the chair to sign.
5.10: Approve temporary reduced hours of Vital Statistics due to staffing shortages for the period of April 3, 2023, through April 7, 2023, to be closed from noon to 5 p.m. each day.
5.11: Waive competitive bidding per 38.2(3) and approve amendment to agreement between the county of Lake and Tyler Technologies to provide case management software and associated services for the period of April 1, 2023, to March 31, 2024, for an amount not to exceed $46,880 for the first year, $57,474 for the second year, and $72,498 for the third year, and authorize the chair to sign.
5.12: Sitting as the Lake County Sanitation District Board of Directors, a) waive the competitive bidding process, pursuant to Lake County Code Section 2-38.4 Cooperative Purchases; b) authorize Special Districts Administrator/assistant purchasing agent to issue a purchase order not to exceed $130,000 to U-Rock Utility Equipment for the purchase of a Portable Rovver X Basic System; c) Approve budget transfer allocating money from object code 63.05 to 62.74.
TIMED ITEMS
6.2, 9:07 a.m.: Presentation of proclamation of appreciation for Registrar of Voters staff, poll workers, and county key staff on successfully conducting the June and November 2022.
6.3, 9:30 a.m.: a) Consideration of overview of Big Valley Band of Pomo Indians and Lake County Watershed Protection Districts Adobe Creek Managed Flow Strategy Project being submitted under the Office of Planning and Research’s 2022-2023 Adaptation Planning Grant Program; and b) review and consideration of letter of support from the Board of Directors of the Watershed Protection District for the proposed project.
6.4, 10:30 a.m.: Consideration of Municipal Advisory Committee (MAC) transition of the Lucerne Area Town Hall (LATH), initially known as (MRTH) Middle Region Town Hall; to (CeRTH) Central Region Town Hall.
UNTIMED ITEMS
7.2: Consideration of a letter documenting written comments in response to Cal Fire’s State Responsibility Area (SRA) Fire Hazard Severity Zones (FHSZ) Maps.
7.3: Consideration of consistency of the scope of the Lake County Fish & Wildlife Advisory Committee with needs to support the population of the chi/Clear Lake hitch, and possible direction to staff.
7.4: Consideration of the county of Lake acting as lead agency on a grant application to provide funding for the Lake County Risk Reduction Authority, Lake County Resource Conservation District, Lake County Fire Safe Council, and the Lake County Office of Climate Resiliency as well as funding to implement four hazard mitigation actions from the county of Lake’s 2018 Local Hazard Mitigation Plan.
7.5: Consideration of agreement between the county of Lake and Redwood Community Services Inc. for supportive employment and supportive education program services for fiscal years 2023-2026 for $408,282.
7.6: Consideration of the following advisory board appointments: Child Care Planning Council, Emergency Medical Care Committee, Fish and Wildlife Advisory Committee and Mental Health Board.
7.7: Consideration of updated advisory board application.
CLOSED SESSION
8.1: Conference with legal counsel: Existing litigation pursuant to Gov. Code sec. 54956.9 (d)(1) – FERC Project No. 77, Potter Valley Hydroelectric Project.
8.2: Conference with legal counsel: Existing litigation pursuant to Gov. Code sec. 54956.9(d)(1): In re National Prescription Opiate Litigation MDL No. 2804/Case No. 17-MD-2804.
8.3: Public employee evaluation: Information Technology Director Shane French.
8.4: Public employee evaluation: Health Services Director Jonathan Portney.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.
Reading the latest international climate report can feel overwhelming. It describes how rising temperatures caused by increasing greenhouse gas emissions from human activities are having rapid, widespread effects on the weather, climate and ecosystems in every region of the planet, and it says the risks are escalating faster than scientists expected.
Global temperatures are now 1.1 degree Celsius (2 degrees Fahrenheit) warmer than at the start of the industrial era. Heat waves, storms, fires and floods are harming humans and ecosystems. Hundreds of species have disappeared from regions as temperatures rise, and climate change is causing irreversible changes to sea ice, oceans and glaciers. In some areas, it’s becoming harder to adapt to the changes, the authors write.
Still, there are reasons for optimism – falling renewable energy costs are starting to transform the power sector, for example, and the use of electric vehicles is expanding. But change aren’t happening fast enough, and the window for a smooth transition is closing fast, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report warns. To keep global warming below 1.5 C (2.7 F), it says global greenhouse gas emissions will have to drop 60% by 2035 compared with 2019 levels.
The extent to which current and future generations will experience a hotter world depends on choices made now and in the coming years. The scenarios show expected differences in temperature depending on how high emissions are going forward.IPCC sixth assessment report
In the new report, released March 20, 2023, the IPCC summarizes findings from a series of assessments written over the past eight years and discusses how to stop the damage. In them, hundreds of scientists reviewed the evidence and research.
Here are four essential reads by co-authors of some of those reports, each providing a different snapshot of the changes underway and discussing solutions.
1. More intense storms and flooding
A volunteer fire company assists with evacuation efforts following a flash flood in Helmetta, New Jersey, in August 2021.Tom Brenner / AFP via Getty Images
Many of the most shocking natural disasters of the past few years have involved intense rainfall and flooding.
In Europe, a storm in 2021 set off landslides and sent rivers rushing through villages that had stood for centuries. In 2022, about a third of Pakistan was underwater, and several U.S. communities were hit with extreme flash flooding.
The IPCC warns in the sixth assessment report that the water cycle will continue to intensify as the planet warms. That includes extreme monsoon rainfall, but also increasing drought, greater melting of mountain glaciers, decreasing snow cover and earlier snowmelt, wrote UMass-Lowell climate scientist Mathew Barlow, a co-author of the report examining physical changes.
Annual average precipitation is projected to increase in many areas as the planet warms, particularly in the higher latitudes.IPCC sixth assessment report
“An intensifying water cycle means that both wet and dry extremes and the general variability of the water cycle will increase, although not uniformly around the globe,” Barlow wrote.
“Understanding this and other changes in the water cycle is important for more than preparing for disasters. Water is an essential resource for all ecosystems and human societies.”
2. The longer the delay, the higher the cost
Extreme rainfall filled streets in Dhaka, Bangladesh, in July 2020. Flooding has become common in many South Asia cities.Munir Uz zaman / AFP via Getty Images
The IPCC stressed in its reports that human activities are unequivocally warming the planet and causing rapid changes in the world’s atmosphere, oceans and icy regions.
“Countries can either plan their transformations, or they can face the destructive, often chaotic transformations that will be imposed by the changing climate,” wrote Edward Carr, a Clark University scholar and co-author of the IPCC report focused on adaptation.
The longer countries wait to respond, the greater the damage and cost to contain it. One estimate from Columbia University put the cost of adaptation needed just for urban areas at between US$64 billion and $80 billion a year – and the cost of doing nothing at 10 times that level by mid-century.
“The IPCC assessment offers a stark choice,” Carr wrote. “Does humanity accept this disastrous status quo and the uncertain, unpleasant future it is leading toward, or does it grab the reins and choose a better future?”
3. Transportation is a good place to start
Electric vehicle sales have been accelerating, and new tax incentives and state zero-emissions requirements are expected to boost sales even more.Michael Fousert/Unsplash, CC BY
One crucial sector for reducing greenhouse gas emissions is transportation.
Cutting greenhouse gas emissions to net-zero by mid-century, a target considered necessary to keep global warming below 1.5 C, will require “a major, rapid rethinking of how people get around globally,” wrote Alan Jenn, a transportation scholar at the University of California Davis and co-author on the IPCC report on mitigation.
There are positive signs. Battery costs for electric vehicles have fallen, making them increasingly affordable. In the U.S., the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act offers tax incentives that lower the costs for EV buyers and encourage companies to ramp up production. And several states are considering following California’s requirement that all new cars and light trucks be zero-emissions by 2035.
Costs have fallen for key forms of renewable energy and EV batteries, and adoption of these technologies is rising.IPCC sixth assessment report
“Behavioral and other systemic changes will also be needed to cut greenhouse gas emissions dramatically from this sector,” Jenn wrote.
For example, many countries saw their transportation emissions drop during COVID-19 as more people were allowed to work from home. Bike sharing in urban areas, public transit-friendly cities and avoiding urban sprawl can help cut emissions even further. Aviation and shipping are more challenging to decarbonize, but efforts are underway.
He adds, however, that it’s important to remember that the effectiveness of electrifying transportation ultimately depends on cleaning up the electricity grid.
The IPCC reports discuss several other important steps to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, including shifting energy from fossil fuels to renewable sources, making buildings more energy efficient and improving food production, as well as ways to adapt to changes that can no longer be avoided.
“For example, renewable energy is now generally less expensive than fossil fuels, so a shift to clean energy can often save money,” they wrote. Electric vehicle costs are falling. Communities and infrastructure can be redesigned to better manage natural hazards such as wildfires and storms. Corporate climate risk disclosures can help investors better recognize the hazards and push those companies to build resilience and reduce their climate impact.
“The problem is that these solutions aren’t being deployed fast enough,” Lempert and Gilmore wrote. “In addition to pushback from industries, people’s fear of change has helped maintain the status quo.” Meeting the challenge, they said, starts with embracing innovation and change.
Editor’s note: This story is a roundup of articles from The Conversation’s archives.
Yurok Firefighter Faith Tracy, a Yurok citizen, performs a cultural burn on the Yurok Reservation in Northern California. Photo by Matt Mais/Yurok Tribe. NORTHERN CALIFORNIA — A program that aims to bring more diversity into the firefighting profession is seeking Native American women trainees.
Through the Yurok Tribe’s partnership with Redwood National Park, the Yurok Fire Department was selected to train four female firefighters for the National Park Service’s forward-looking Women in Fire Program.
“It is a huge privilege to train these firefighters for the Women in Fire Program,” said Yurok Fire Chief Rod Mendes, who has trained hundreds of firefighters. “We look forward to providing four Native American women the skills and experience they need to acquire good-paying jobs with tribal, federal or state wildland fire departments.”
"It is the goal of this program to recruit, train, and offer exposure to multiple aspects of wildland fire in addition to exposure to the planning and implementation of prescribed fire projects,” said Redwood National Park Fire Management Officer Rick Young.
“After completion of this program the participants will not only be able to compete for a career in wildland fire as a crewperson, but hopefully be inspired to continue on to become future leaders in the fire service,” said Young. “I’m excited to partner with the Yurok Tribe in this effort and I hope to expand the program in the coming years, creating more opportunities for a large segment of our community that is currently underrepresented within the fire service."
With $100,000 from the National Park Service, or NPS, the Yurok Fire Department is recruiting four Native American women to participate in the paid program.
Once hired, the Yurok Fire Department will put the women through an intensive wildland fire training academy focused on the fundamentals of wildland firefighting.
Based out of the department’s headquarters on the Yurok Reservation, the comprehensive training will consist of classroom instruction and hands-on skill-building exercises.
The classroom part of the course will cover a wide variety of topics, such as wildland fire behavior, firefighting tactics and the Incident Command System, as well as communications, fire line safety and situational awareness.
In the field, the four trainees will perform exercises with many different forms of firefighting equipment, ranging from fire pumps to chainsaws. They will also learn to work as a team.
The in-depth training will prepare program participants to pass the written and physical tests required to receive an interagency-certified Incident Qualifications Card, or Red Card, and a Firefighter 2 credential, which will qualify them to land firefighting jobs anywhere in the United States.
After they complete the training and certification process, the four women will work out of the Yurok fire house in Tulley Creek. On a daily basis, the firefighters will be assigned duties and respond to calls for service as members of the Yurok fire crew until the end of the 2023 fire season.
Their duties may include fighting local forest fires, participating in cultural burns on tribal lands and managing woodland fuels to protect elders’ homes.
The female firefighters will also spend stints with Redwood National Park and US Forest Service fire crews, which will further expand their skill sets.
The Yurok Fire Department is the first tribal firefighting organization to administer the transformational Women in Fire Program in California.
The National Park Service launched the program in 2021 in an effort to make its workforce more resilient and encourage more females to pursue leadership positions within the male-dominated profession. Women currently make up just 12% of the federal wildland fire workforce.
Yurok Fire Chief Rod Mendes will oversee the Women in Fire Program training, which will be based out of the Yurok fire house. The four female Native American trainees will become credentialed wildland firefighters. Photo by Matt Mais/Yurok Tribe.
The Yurok Tribe and the park service recognize that diversity drives innovation, which is needed now more than ever before as the land managers confront climate change, drought and longer, more severe fire seasons.
Prior to partnering with the Yurok Fire Department, NPS implemented Women in Fire Programs with conservation corps in multiple states.
The Yurok Fire Department is an all-risk, all-hazard organization that focuses on fire detection, prevention and suppression in conjunction with traditional and conventional fuels management. The chartered tribal agency fights wildfires in the local area and across the US.
In addition to extinguishing fires, the Yurok crew conducts cultural burns to moderate forest fuel loads, improve wildlife habitat and increase access to traditional basket-weaving materials on tribal lands. When they are not contending with fires or performing controlled burns, the Yurok crew works on projects that reduce fire risk on the reservation.
The Yurok Fire Department is led by Chief Rod Mendes. Chief Mendes has more than 35 years of fire officer leadership experience, including lengthy terms as a district fire management officer for the Klamath National Forest and as the Chief of Fire and Office of Emergency Services for the Hoopa Valley Tribe, and over 20 years with Inter-agency Incident Management teams. He is also a governor-appointed member of California’s Homeland Security Advisory Committee.
Chief Mendes will design and oversee the Women in Fire Program training.
“I can say from experience Chief Mendes is a tremendous resource for new firefighters, especially those who want to climb the ranks. The park service couldn’t have selected a better mentor for participants in the Women in Fire Program,” said Yurok Firefighter and Yurok citizen Faith Tracy.
To apply for the Women in Fire Program on the Yurok Reservation, please fill out the Yurok Tribe employment application, which can be found here.
Middletown Art Center staff members Ruth Richards, Kilak Malicay and Wayla Brown lay out pieces for the “Eagle & Condor” ceramic mural cocreated by people across Lake County, California. Courtesy photo. MIDDLETOWN, Calif. — The Middletown Art Center has received a major grant award for a new project focused on the Latinx community.
The $188,744 grant from the California Natural Resources Agency and California Cultural and Historical Endowment will fund the center’s “Raíces Hermosas — Gorgeous Roots” project.
The Middletown Art Center, or MAC, designed “Raíces Hermosas” to uplift and connect the Latinx community, both seen and hidden, to the center to the community at large through art, culturally focused events and art making.
“We have to build trust with our Latinx community so that they feel welcome at all decision-making tables,” said Zabdy Neria, a MAC Board director, Konocti Unified School Board trustee and behavioral health practitioner who initiated the project. “Through the shared language of art, music and dance, we can instill the message that they (we) belong.”
At the center of the Raíces Hermosas project is a curated exhibit of contemporary expressions of Latinx culture, roots, and issues by local and regional Latinx artists.
Project activities include guided school field trips to the gallery and art studio during the exhibit for 3,600 Lake County students as well as pre/post visit curriculum, weekend artmaking workshops and cultural events at MAC, and community-engaged artmaking at festivals.
“We are excited to share this project with the people of Lake County! It raises awareness, has a robust education component, and brings us together. It also brings funding for jobs into our local economy during the year-long grant period,” said MAC’s Executive and Artistic Director Lisa Kaplan. “We are grateful for the opportunity to contribute to the local economy and community in a meaningful way and look forward to welcoming people from across Lake County and beyond to MAC.”
Right now, the MAC is seeking bilingual project coordination support. You can learn more about this job opportunity on MAC’s website.
“This funding will support projects across the state that lift up history and culture that has been underrepresented in the past and enable more people to learn these remarkable stories,” said California Natural Resources Secretary Wade Crowfoot.
This grant award, while a significant amount, is entirely dedicated to the Raíces Hermosas project, meaning, MAC must continue its regular fundraising activities and relies on community support for regular operations.
LAKE COUNTY, Calif. — Lake County Animal Care and Control has a new puppy plus plenty of adult dogs waiting to go to new homes.
Dogs available for adoption this week include mixes of Australian cattle dog, blue heeler, border collie, boxer, Cardigan Welsh Corgi, Chihuahua, German shepherd, Great Pyrenees, hound, Labrador retriever, mastiff, pit bull and treeing walker coonhound.
Dogs that are adopted from Lake County Animal Care and Control are either neutered or spayed, microchipped and, if old enough, given a rabies shot and county license before being released to their new owner. License fees do not apply to residents of the cities of Lakeport or Clearlake.
The following dogs at the Lake County Animal Care and Control shelter have been cleared for adoption.
Call Lake County Animal Care and Control at 707-263-0278 or visit the shelter online for information on visiting or adopting.
This 2-month-old female Chihuahua puppy is in kennel No. B3, ID No. LCAC-A-4946. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Female Chihuahua puppy
This 2-month-old female Chihuahua puppy has a short tan coat with black markings.
She is in kennel No. B3, ID No. LCAC-A-4946.
This 3-month-old female American pit bull terrier puppy is in kennel No. 4a, ID No. LCAC-A-4787. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Female pit bull terrier puppy
This 3-month-old female American pit bull terrier puppy has a short brindle coat.
She is in kennel No. 4a, ID No. LCAC-A-4787.
This 3-month-old female American pit bull terrier puppy is in kennel No. 4b, ID No. LCAC-A-4788. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Female pit bull terrier puppy
This 3-month-old female American pit bull terrier puppy has a short black and white coat.
She is in kennel No. 4b, ID No. LCAC-A-4788.
This 1-year-old female pit bull terrier is in kennel No. 5, ID No. LCAC-A-4873. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Female pit bull terrier
This 1-year-old female pit bull terrier has a short black and white coat.
She is in kennel No. 5, ID No. LCAC-A-4873.
This 1-year-old male Labrador retriever mix is in kennel No. 6, ID No. 4841. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Male Labrador retriever mix
This 1-year-old male Labrador retriever mix has a short black coat with white markings.
He is in kennel No. 6, ID No. 4841.
“Able” is a 6-year-old male coonhound mix in kennel No. 7, ID No. LCAC-A-4773. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. ‘Able’
“Able” is a 6-year-old male coonhound mix with a short black and tan coat.
He is in kennel No. 7, ID No. LCAC-A-4773.
This one and a half year old female German shepherd is in kennel No. 8, ID No. LCAC-A-4898. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Female German shepherd
This one and a half year old female German shepherd has a black and tan coat.
She is in kennel No. 8, ID No. LCAC-A-4898.
This 1-year-old female border collie is in kennel No. 11, ID No. LCAC-A-4903. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Female border collie
This 1-year-old female border collie has a black and white coat, and one brown eye and one blue eye.
She is in kennel No. 11, ID No. LCAC-A-4903.
“Luigi” is a 2-year-old male pit bull terrier in kennel No. 12, ID No. LCAC-A-4742. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. ‘Luigi’
“Luigi” is a 2-year-old male pit bull terrier with a short red and white coat.
He is in kennel No. 12, ID No. LCAC-A-4742.
“Oreo” is a 2-year-old male treeing walker coonhound in kennel No. 13, ID No. LCAC-A-4738. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. ‘Oreo’
“Oreo” is a 2-year-old male treeing walker coonhound with a short tricolor coat.
He is in kennel No. 13, ID No. LCAC-A-4738.
This 2-year-old female German shepherd-hound mix is in kennel No. 15, ID No. LCAC-A-4816. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Female German shepherd-hound mix
This 2-year-old female German shepherd-hound mix has a black and tan coat.
She is in kennel No. 15, ID No. LCAC-A-4816.
This 2-year-old male German shepherd mix is in kennel No. 16, ID No. LCAC-A-4835. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Male German shepherd mix
This 2-year-old male German shepherd mix has a red and white coat.
He is in kennel No. 16, ID No. LCAC-A-4835.
This female pit bull-Labrador retriever mix is in kennel No. 17, ID No. LCAC-A-4692. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Female pit bull-Labrador retriever mix
This female pit bull-Labrador retriever mix has a short tricolor coat.
She is in kennel No. 17, ID No. LCAC-A-4692.
“Rusty” is a 2-year-old male Cardigan Welsh Corgi in kennel No. 18, ID No. LCAC-A-4418. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. ‘Rusty’
“Rusty” is a 2-year-old male Cardigan Welsh Corgi with a short tricolor coat.
He is in kennel No. 18, ID No. LCAC-A-4418.
This one and a half year old male pit bull terrier is in kennel No. 19, ID No. LCAC-A-4843. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Male pit bull terrier
This one and a half year old male pit bull terrier has a black coat with white markings.
He is in kennel No. 19, ID No. LCAC-A-4843.
This 2-year-old female Australian cattle dog-blue heeler is in kennel No. 20, ID No. LCAC-A-4836. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Female Australian cattle dog-blue heeler
This 2-year-old female Australian cattle dog-blue heeler has a short blue and black coat.
She is in kennel No. 20, ID No. LCAC-A-4836.
This 1-year-old male Anatolian shepherd is in kennel No. 22, ID No. LCAC-A-4844. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Male Anatolian shepherd
This 1-year-old male Anatolian shepherd has a black and tan coat.
He is in kennel No. 22, ID No. LCAC-A-4844.
“Bruno” is a 9-month-old male mastiff-pit bull mix in kennel No. 23, ID No. LCAC-A-4789. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. ‘Bruno’
“Bruno” is a 9-month-old male mastiff-pit bull mix with a short tan coat.
He is in kennel No. 23, ID No. LCAC-A-4789.
This 8-year-old male boxer-pit bull mix is in kennel No. 26, ID No. LCAC-A-4678. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Male boxer-pit bull mix
This 8-year-old male boxer-pit bull mix has a short brown brindle coat.
He is in kennel No. 26, ID No. LCAC-A-4678.
This 2-year-old male Great Pyrenees is in kennel No. 28, ID No. LCAC-A-4821. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Male Great Pyrenees
This 2-year-old male Great Pyrenees has a long white coat.
He is in kennel No. 28, ID No. LCAC-A-4821.
This 1-year-old male German shepherd is in kennel No. 29, ID No. LCAC-A-4710. Photo courtesy of Lake County Animal Care and Control. Male German shepherd
This 1-year-old male German shepherd has a short black and tan coat.
He is in kennel No. 29, ID No. LCAC-A-4710.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.
Grace Melo, Texas A&M University; Pourya Valizadeh, Texas A&M University, and Rodolfo M. Nayga Jr., Texas A&M University
We looked specifically at kids whose families were participating in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program – commonly known as SNAP – the government program that helps low-income Americans afford food.
The government began to boost SNAP benefits in early 2020 to help offset pandemic-driven food insecurity for participating families, which now number around 41 million.
To learn whether these extra benefits affected children’s mental and emotional health, we analyzed five years of data collected by the National Survey of Children’s Health on 30,748 low-income families with children aged 6 to 17 years. The data, which included both families who were and were not getting SNAP benefits, covered the four years prior to the pandemic, as well as 2020.
Among the 8,680 families getting SNAP benefits during this period, 38% had at least one child with problems such as doctor-diagnosed mental, emotional, developmental or behavioral health issues – including anxiety and depression.
To assess whether the temporarily expanded benefits had an impact on these children, we conducted a “difference in differences” analysis: We compared data regarding children whose families enrolled in the SNAP program over time with children whose families didn’t get those benefits. In addition, we considered the potential influence of several factors that could play a role, such as parents’ mental health.
We found that children in families getting SNAP benefits in 2020 did not generally experience any change in their mental or emotional health compared to prior years, despite the heavy stress of the pandemic.
While 2020’s extra SNAP benefits protected children’s mental and emotional health, they did not improve it. This suggests that actually reducing food insecurity for low-income families would have required additional steps.
We are now studying the effects of pandemic-related changes to the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children, better known as WIC.
We are looking at, for example, how expanding WIC benefits to cover canned, frozen and dried fruits and vegetables in addition to fresh produce has affected the low-income families’ purchasing behavior. Our team for this research also includes public health and nutrition scholars Alexandra MacMillan Uribe and Elizabeth Racine,
What is not known
When we did our study, data from the years after 2020 wasn’t yet available, so we couldn’t investigate the potential impact of subsequent pandemic-related changes to SNAP benefits. Notably, in 2021, the federal government increased maximum benefit levels by 15% and extended the extra $95 or more in monthly food assistance for the lowest-income households.
When Silicon Valley and Signature banks failed in early March 2023, government regulators rushed in to guarantee deposits and protect bank customers. Under current banking regulations, though, there was no obligation for the government to step in.
Now, both Democratic and Republican politicians are making pronouncements about whether bipartisan-backed deregulation in 2018 led to the banks’ collapse and whether the banking industry needs more government intervention.
Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and U.S. Rep. Katie Porter of California, both Democrats, introduced a bill on March 15, 2023, to restore stiff banking regulations that they maintain would have prevented the practices that led to the recent bank collapses. But some Republicans, including U.S. Rep. Andy Barr of Kentucky, say lax government policy that included overspending – which Barr says, fueled inflation, as well as long-term low interest rates – not deregulation, was behind the banks’ failures.
In dispute are requirements in the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act that were rolled back in 2018. Dodd-Frank put in place financial regulatory changes in response to the 2008 global financial meltdown. The legislation included among its requirements one that banks with US$50 billion in assets be subject to strict standards. Some lawmakers, including Porter and Warren, say those requirements should have remained intact.
The Conversation asked Gerard W. Comizio, a law professor, former Wall Street attorney and former senior Treasury Department official, to explain some of the problems that spurred Silicon Valley Bank, Signature Bank and another bank to fail.
What caused Silicon Valley, Signature and a third bank, Silvergate, to fail?
Significant withdrawals at all three banks caused cash crises that could not be addressed by selling assets, such as bank notes and bonds. In the case of all three banks, sales of their assets would have triggered significant additional losses, since their portfolios were worth less than they paid for them and interest rates were rising.
While some aspects of each failure were different, there were common elements, and a certain level of Murphy’s law – the idea that if something can go wrong, it will. In the case of these banks, everything went wrong.
In the last three months of 2022, Silvergate had a record $1 billion loss, due to heavy lending to troubled and failed crypto trading exchanges. And its interest rate-sensitive securities portfolio became kindling for the current crisis.
Bond prices plunged, creating billions of dollars in paper losses for Silicon Valley Bank, popularly known as SVB.
To shore up its cash assets, in the face of increasing customer withdrawals, SVB sold $21 billion in bonds at a $1.8 billion loss.
Former Sen. Chris Dodd speaks at a news conference on July 21, 2015, to mark the fifth anniversary of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act.Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call via Getty Images
Which regulations from the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act were designed to prevent banking failures?
Section 165 of the Dodd-Frank Act adopted so-called “enhanced prudential regulation” rules for all banking organizations with more than $50 billion in assets, designating them as “systemically important financial institutions,” popularly known by the term “too big to fail.” These standards were designed to be more stringent than those applied to smaller banks. Lawmakers believed the larger institutions posed far greater risk to the financial stability of the U.S.
These stricter rules required, among other things, that the banks deemed too big to fail periodically update for the Federal Reserve and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. a comprehensive resolution plan. Dubbed the Living Will, that plan details a company’s plans for a “rapid and orderly” dissolution of the bank in the event it is failing or has already failed. In addition, these too-big-to-fail banks had a requirement to periodically assess their risk under a variety of market conditions, including rises in interest rates and risk hedging strategies. The rules also said designated banks had significantly higher capital requirements.
No longer required to adhere to those key provisions of the Dodd-Frank Act, the failed banks did not. Arguably, the provisions could have saved them.
Why weren’t the banks subject to those regulations?
In 2018, Congress, in a bipartisan vote, with the support of then-President Donald Trump’s administration, all of the federal banking agencies and the banking industry, passed the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief and Consumer Protection Act. It amended the Dodd-Frank Act to substantially reduce the number of banks subject to the more stringent regulation by raising the threshold at which banks posed potential systemic risk, from $50 billion up to $250 billion.
President Trump after signing the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act bill on May 24, 2018.Win McNamee via Getty Images
If the Dodd-Frank Act had remained intact, would the banks have failed?
There are a number of arguments as to whether these failures could have been prevented and addressed faster if the Dodd-Frank standards had still been in place. These standards were arguably designed to specifically prevent and address the type of circumstances that triggered these recent bank failures: multiple failures and contagion in the financial system, market panic, deposit runs and liquidity crisis.
For example, abiding by Living Wills and stress testing would have identified problems far earlier and potentially required these banks to address a number of potential red flags that constituted higher risk, such as:
Interest rate risk in the banks’ securities portfolio investments, and the consequences of liquidating those investments at a significant loss in the event of a cash crisis;
Lack of interest rate risk hedging strategies;
Excessive uninsured deposits that posed a risk to the bank if customers withdrew their money en masse; and
The need to hold higher-than-normal levels of money to address their risks.
Ironically, in taking steps to provide unprecedented deposit insurance coverage to uninsured deposits at these banks, the U.S. Treasury, the Fed and the FDIC issued a joint statement on March 12 that they were invoking the systemic risk exception which allowed them to replace depositors’ money, even though the law was changed in 2018 to make clear banks of their size no longer posed systemic risk.
Without water, life on Earth could not exist as it does today. Understanding the history of water in the universe is critical to understanding how planets like Earth come to be.
Astronomers typically refer to the journey water takes from its formation as individual molecules in space to its resting place on the surfaces of planets as “the water trail.” The trail starts in the interstellar medium with hydrogen and oxygen gas and ends with oceans and ice caps on planets, with icy moons orbiting gas giants and icy comets and asteroids that orbit stars. The beginnings and ends of this trail are easy to see, but the middle has remained a mystery.
I am an astronomer who studies the formation of stars and planets using observations from radio and infrared telescopes. In a new paper, my colleagues and I describe the first measurements ever made of this previously hidden middle part of the water trail and what these findings mean for the water found on planets like Earth.
Star and planet formation is an intertwined process that starts with a cloud of molecules in space.Bill Saxton, NRAO/AUI/NSF, CC BY
Stars begin to form when parts of the collapsing cloud reach a certain density and heat up enough to start fusing hydrogen atoms together. Since only a small fraction of the gas initially collapses into the newborn protostar, the rest of the gas and dust forms a flattened disk of material circling around the spinning, newborn star. Astronomers call this a proto-planetary disk.
As icy dust particles collide with each other inside a proto-planetary disk, they begin to clump together. The process continues and eventually forms the familiar objects of space like asteroids, comets, rocky planets like Earth and gas giants like Jupiter or Saturn.
There are two potential pathways that water in our solar system could have taken. The first, called chemical inheritance, is when the water molecules originally formed in the interstellar medium are delivered to proto-planetary disks and all the bodies they create without going through any changes.
The second theory is called chemical reset. In this process, the heat from the formation of the proto-planetary disk and newborn star breaks apart water molecules, which then reform once the proto-planetary disk cools.
Normal hydrogen, or protium, does not contain a neutron in its nucleus, while deuterium contains one neutron, making it heavier.Dirk Hünniger/Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA
To test these theories, astronomers like me look at the ratio between normal water and a special kind of water called semi-heavy water. Water is normally made of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom. Semi-heavy water is made of one oxygen atom, one hydrogen atom and one atom of deuterium – a heavier isotope of hydrogen with an extra neutron in its nucleus.
The ratio of semi-heavy to normal water is a guiding light on the water trail – measuring the ratio can tell astronomers a lot about the source of water. Chemical models and experiments have shown that about 1,000 times more semi-heavy water will be produced in the cold interstellar medium than in the conditions of a protoplanetary disk.
This difference means that by measuring the ratio of semi-heavy to normal water in a place, astronomers can tell whether that water went through the chemical inheritance or chemical reset pathway.
V883 Orionis is a young star system with a rare star at its center that makes measuring water in the proto-planetary cloud, shown in the cutaway, possible.ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO), B. Saxton (NRAO/AUI/NSF), CC BY
Measuring water during the formation of a planet
Comets have a ratio of semi-heavy to normal water almost perfectly in line with chemical inheritance, meaning the water hasn’t undergone a major chemical change since it was first created in space. Earth’s ratio sits somewhere in between the inheritance and reset ratio, making it unclear where the water came from.
To truly determine where the water on planets comes from, astronomers needed to find a goldilocks proto-planetary disk – one that is just the right temperature and size to allow observations of water. Doing so has proved to be incredibly difficult. It is possible to detect semi-heavy and normal water when water is a gas; unfortunately for astronomers, the vast majority of proto-plantary disks are very cold and contain mostly ice, and it is nearly impossible to measure water ratios from ice at interstellar distances.
A breakthrough came in 2016, when my colleagues and I were studying proto-planetary disks around a rare type of young star called FU Orionis stars. Most young stars consume matter from the proto-planetary disks around them. FU Orionis stars are unique because they consume matter about 100 times faster than typical young stars and, as a result, emit hundreds of times more energy. Due to this higher energy output, the proto-planetary disks around FU Orionis stars are heated to much higher temperatures, turning ice into water vapor out to large distances from the star.
Using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array, a powerful radio telescope in northern Chile, we discovered a large, warm proto-planetary disk around the Sunlike young star V883 Ori, about 1,300 light years from Earth in the constellation Orion.
V883 Ori emits 200 times more energy than the Sun, and my colleagues and I recognized that it was an ideal candidate to observe the semi-heavy to normal water ratio.
These results fill in the gap of the water trail forging a direct link between water in the interstellar medium, protostars, proto-planetary disks and planets like Earth through the process of inheritance, not chemical reset.
The new results show definitively that a substantial portion of the water on Earth most likely formed billions of years ago, before the Sun had even ignited. Confirming this missing piece of water’s path through the universe offers clues to origins of water on Earth. Scientists have previously suggested that most water on Earth came from comets impacting the planet. The fact that Earth has less semi-heavy water than comets and V883 Ori, but more than chemical reset theory would produce, means that water on Earth likely came from more than one source.