Monday, 09 December 2024

News

LUCERNE – State Department of Fish & Game officials will be out in full force on the lake again today after hundreds more dead birds were found Tuesday.

 

DFG veterinarians ruled last week that avian cholera was the cause of death for thousands of ducks on the lake this month.

 

Lynette Shimek, one of Lake County's DFG game wardens, reported Tuesday evening that 886 dead dead birds, mostly ruddy ducks, were collected that day by teams on three boats.

 

Game wardens Shimek and Loren Freeman led a small group of volunteers in picking up dead birds over the weekend while nearly a dozen other DFG staff returned to the Gray Lodge Wildlife Area.

 

However, Shimek said that rough weather prevented them from spending any time on the water Saturday; on Sunday, she added, they only had a four-hour window in which they could remain on the water.

 

The hundreds of birds found Tuesday, said Shimek, could have died over the weekend.

 

About 39 dead birds were found between Kono Tayee and south of Rattlesnake Island on Tuesday, said Shimek. DFG went looking for birds there after an area resident reported seeing numerous dead birds in the area.

 

“That was not as many as we had feared,” she said.

 

Most of the birds picked up Tuesday were found in the lake center, straight off from Lucerne, Shimek said. That pattern is consistent with DFG findings last week, and with the die-off patterns in the lake's first avian cholera outbreak in January 2004, in which more than 7,000 ducks and wild birds died.

 

Shimek, who is acting as the local incident commander, reported that DFG had sent more staff back in to help with collection by Tuesday afternoon. DFG has emphasized collecting the dead animals as a way of preventing the disease from spreading.

 

Four boats with a total of 10 DFG staff will be out again today, said Shimek, to continue collection.

 

Shimek said assessment of the situation won't be complete until they go out on the water again today and cover the same areas looking for new dead birds.

 

Tuesday's numbers bring the total of dead birds collected to about 6,200, said Shimek.

 

Andy Atkinson, a senior wildlife biologist who was on scene last week, has said he expects this die-off will equal the 2004 event, Shimek reported.

 

Atkinson has not returned to Lake County, said Shimek, because he has had to respond to other avian cholera outbreaks that now are taking place in the valley.

 

Shimek thanked local residents for their diligence in reporting dead animals, and also thanked local volunteers for their ongoing help in collecting the birds.

 

E-mail Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

 

{mos_sb_discuss:2}

LAKE COUNTY – Two local Indian tribes have confirmed that a Bay Area developer in negotiations to purchase Konocti Harbor Resort & Spa has contacted them about partnering in an off-reservation Indian casino there. 

District 5 Supervisor Rob Brown said in early January that he had received information that Darius Anderson and his firm, Kenwood Investments, were negotiating with five local tribes to form a compact and locate a casino at the resort.

 

Anderson is currently involved in a purchase agreement to buy Konocti Harbor form the UA Local Convalescent Fund.

 

Two tribes, Clearlake Oaks' Elem Nation and the Habematolel Pomo of Upper Lake, have confirmed that Anderson approached them about being part of a Konocti Harbor casino.

 

Repeated calls to Darius Anderson and his business partner, Jay Wallace, have not been returned.

 

Elem Nation Tribal Chair Ray Brown Sr. said Anderson approached Elem more than a year ago about the plan, but that he didn't feel comfortable with it.

 

“There was too much demand on our side,” said Brown, explaining that Anderson wanted them to come up with a large amount of money for the deal.

 

Brown said his tribe already has a casino compact in the works, and that the Elem casino will be located at the colony in Clearlake Oaks.

 

There was discussion between Brown and Anderson about using a paddle wheel boat to transport guests between the casinos, but Brown said the entire plan “just got too far out of reach.”

 

Brown also voiced concerns about traffic and roads in the area of Konocti Harbor, and questioned whether increased traffic from a casino there would be feasible.

 

Eventually, Brown said, he backed off of negotiating with Anderson, but not before Anderson made several big promises – including buying Rattlesnake Island for the tribe. The 53-acre island is listed for sale on the Internet for $2,500,000.

 

That property, currently owned by John Nady, is held as a sacred site by the tribe. Jim Brown, Ray Brown's brother and a gaming commissioner, said the tribe does not plan to site a casino on the island.

 

Ray Brown said his tribe is going forward with its own casino plan. “It's not going to be a big one,” he said. “We don't want to go big yet.”

 

He said he has a meeting with an investor next week to discuss the Elem casino. Brown said as soon as funding is in place he estimates it will take about 18 months for construction.

 

Jim Brown said he had met Anderson several times in person, and that Anderson also visited the tribe's office in Clearlake Oaks. He reported that Anderson told tribal members that, due to his contacts with the state Democratic Party, he could get the plan “fast-tracked” and completed in a minimum of five years.

 

Jim Brown said a concern for the tribe was why Anderson was coming to a county where there were already several tribes with gaming plans.

 

However, he noted, “Under the compact, each tribe can have two casinos. A lot of people don't know that.”

 

Rob Rosette, an attorney representing the Habematolel Pomo of Upper Lake, said Anderson discussed the Konocti Harbor casino plan with that tribe as well during a few brief discussions between a year and a half and two years ago. Rosette said he didn't recall the exact context of those conversations.

 

However, the discussion didn't bear fruit, he said.

 

“Upper Lake was not a good match for that group,” said Rosette, explaining that the tribe wished to pursue its casino plan in Upper Lake, where the tribe has cultural ties.

 

The Habematolel casino would be located in Upper Lake on restored lands, said Rosette, which is a far different set of laws that Anderson's plan would work under.

 

Rosette said the Habematolel project is “going great,” and is making efforts to work responsibly with local government.

 

“It's a very good project, and that's because the tribe has acted like a good neighbor, and have conducted themselves responsibly,” said Rosette, adding that he believes the Upper Lake casino is “inevitable.”

 

His best guess is that the Habematolel casino will open for business sometime in 2008.

 

 

Other tribes say they haven't been contacted

 

Some other local tribes originally mentioned as being involved in the plan say they're not.

 

Bennett Wright, tribal administrator for the Scotts Valley Band of Pomo Indians, said he'd never heard of Anderson or Kenwood Investments, and that his tribe hasn't been contacted about a casino at Konocti Harbor.

 

The Scotts Valley Tribe is busy with a plan to locate a casino in Richmond, said Wright.

 

In November, the Richmond City Council approved a 20-year, $335 million agreement with the tribe to provide infrastructure and services for the proposed casino, even though it is located outside of the city's boundaries, according to a Contra Costa Times report.

 

The Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors, however, unanimously passed a resolution opposing gaming expansion in any part of the county, according to the Contra Costa Times.

 

Tracey Avila, Robinson Rancheria's tribal chair, said that tribe has not been contacted about the deal. Neither has the Pinoleville band of Pomos, according to their chair Leona Williams. Middletown Rancheria's tribal chair, Jose Simon, said they have not been contacted either.

 

Calls to Big Valley Rancheria and Potter Valley Rancheria were not returned. Marshall McKay, tribal chair of the Rumsey Band of Wintun Indians, who have Cache Creek Casino, also could not be reached.

 

Attempts to contact the Koi Nation of Lower Lake also were unsuccessful. 

 

 

Local concerns arise over deal

 

The plan has generated considerable local concern in the past month, during which time Supervisor Brown began circulating a petition against a potential casino at Konocti Harbor.

 

He's also had the issue placed on the Feb. 6 Board of Supervisors agenda.

 

At that meeting, Brown plans to ask the board to approve a resolution in which the county will take a formal stand against Anderson's casino plan.

 

Brown also plans to take the matter to Washington, D.C. in March, when he's scheduled to discuss it with Congressman Mike Thompson and Sen. Dianne Feinstein's staff.

 

In a recent letter to Brown, Thompson stated, “I have a long-standing policy that tribal governments need to work with and secure the approval of any city or county government that would be impacted by the establishment of an Indian casino. I realize that this can be a lengthy process but community support is an essential element of successful legislation.”

 

On Jan. 24 both Brown and District 3 Supervisor Denise Rushing met with Cheryl Schmit, director of Stand Up For California, a group that studies gaming in California and its impacts on communities.

 

Schmit said it was a “good meeting,” with local officials asking a lot of good questions about the casino plan.

 

The Konocti Harbor plan, Schmit explained, is an off-reservation proposal, which would require gubernatorial concurrence, which she said she doubts would be given.

 

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger issued a May 2005 proclamation in which he said he would only gaming on newly acquired land in special cases. Those stipulations include not locating a casino in an urban area, having the support of local governments, there is way to prove the community's support such as through an advisory vote, and that the plan offers benefits apart from financial contributions to the state, community or tribe.

 

Darrel Ng, an assistant press secretary for Schwarzenegger's office, also referred to guidelines in the Indian Regulatory Gaming Act (IRGA), which generally don't authorize gaming on lands acquired by tribes after 1988 “unless the land acquired is within or contiguous to existing Indian land or to former land of the tribe if the tribe no longer has a reservation.”

 

The IGRA said those stipulations can only be waived if a casino project “would not be detrimental to the surrounding community under certain circumstances,” and if the governor agreed with the plan.

 

Schmit said it could still be done, but would need a congressional act or a claim of restored lands. “These are not easy alternatives,” she said.

 

She added, “I wonder what Mr. Anderson is really trying to do there.”

 

Columnist Matt Smith of SF Weekly, in two columns published in January, said he believes Anderson is drawing on his political contacts to push the deal through.

 

Smith points to the fact that Sen. Barbara Boxer wrote legislation restoring federal recognition to the Coast Miwok and Graton Rancheria in Sonoma County. At the time, her son, Doug, worked with Anderson at Kenwood Investments, which is now working on a Vegas-style casino for the Graton Rancheria which would be located in Rohnert Park.

 

Schmit said that plan is still ongoing, and that an environmental impact study is due. However, she noted, that tribe can only acquire the land for a casino under the restored lands stipulation, and Schwarzenegger stated in a letter last year that he didn't believe it met the restored lands criteria.

 

In the midst of all of this, Konocti Harbor is at the center of a federal lawsuit. Filed two years ago by the Department of Labor, the suit alleges that Local 38 of the United Association of Plumbers, Pipefitters and Journeymen – which controls the convalescent fund that owns Konocti Harbor – diverted $36 million in assets of five employee benefit plans to renovate and operate the resort.

 

The federal case is due to go to trial this spring.

 

In his columns on Konocti Harbor, Smith has hypothesized that Anderson is using the plan to help Lawrence Mazzola, business manager and financial secretary-treasurer of Local 38 and a well-connected San Francisco politico, out of the lawsuit's hot seat.

 

E-mail Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

 

{mos_sb_discuss:2}

LUCERNE – The numbers of dead ducks collected by state Department of Fish & Game (DFG) officials continued to climb Wednesday. 

The ducks have died from an avian cholera outbreak on the lake, according to DFG veterinarians.

 

Dead and dying animals were first reported nearly two weeks ago, and since then DFG biologists, wardens and volunteers have worked to collect the dead birds to curb the die-of.

 

Most have been ruddy ducks, DFG reported, but small numbers or grebes and other water birds have been found as well.

 

DFG Game Warden Lynette Shimek said Wednesday that 856 dead ruddy ducks were collected that day, bringing the grand total of dead birds found since the outbreak began to 6,801.

 

During sweeps of the lake Wednesday Shimek said they found several birds that had recently died, as well as pockets of birds that had been dead for some time.

 

“Still no end in sight, but we're just hoping for warmer weather,” Shimek said.

 

That's because the ruddy ducks, which like to remain in the open part of the lake, huddle together during winter. That makes the birds more susceptible to catching avian cholera, which travels through the air and close contact, according to DFG biologists.

 

In warmer weather, Shimek said, the birds don't huddle together as tightly.

 

The ducks continue to be found mostly in the open area of the lake, straight out from the Lucerne harbor, said Shimek. Area residents, she added, continue to diligently report any dead birds found on the shoreline.

 

This year's avian cholera outbreak is only the second biologists have recorded on Clear Lake. In size, it's quickly approaching the scope of the first outbreak, which occurred in January 2004, and killed more than 7,000 ruddy ducks and other water birds.

 

Dead birds can be reported to Shimek at her office, 275-8862.

 

E-mail Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

 

{mos_sb_discuss:2}

Image
New CAWG board member, David Weiss. Photo by John Lindblom.
KELSEYVILLE David Weiss, the owner of a vineyard management firm and former chair of the Lake County Winegrape Commission, has been elected to the board of directors for the California Association of Winegrape Growers (CAWG).

NORTHSHORE – Extra State Department of Fish and Game (DFG) staff rolled back into Lucerne Monday night, air boats in tow, in preparation for an assessment today of the situation on the lake following last week's avian cholera die-off.

DFG veterinarians ruled last week that the thousands of ruddy ducks that have died over the past week and a half, interspersed with grebes and other waterfowl, succumbed to avian cholera. That disease commonly affects wild birds during the winter months, the agency reported.

 

Collecting dead animals is critical to keep the disease from spreading, according to DFG.

 

Last week 13 DFG staff using five boats collected nearly 5,000 dead birds, according to Lynette Shimek, a local DFG game warden.

 

Over the weekend, a small crew composed of Shimek, fellow warden Loren Freeman, wildlife rescue group SpiritWild and other volunteers continued the collection effort.

 

Shimek said on Monday evening that they didn't go out on the lake Saturday due to foggy conditions.

 

They also decided it would be good to give sick birds a chance to rest and keep them from moving toward other bird populations.

 

On Sunday the fog only left the volunteers a four-hour window of time to collect animals, Shimek said. In all, they found 120 birds, bringing the collection total to more than 5,000.

 

Although the number of birds found has decreased dramatically – there were days last week when DFG collected 1,000 birds – Shimek said a smaller DFG crew has returned to take a look at the situation and decide if more staff is still needed.

 

Six staff members and three boats will be on the lake today, she said. By day's end, she added, they'll know if more staff will once again be required.

 

Despite finding fewer birds, Shimek reported that the outbreak is still having affecting the birds.

 

“There's still birds dying,” she explained, recounting finding sick and dying birds during Sunday's collection.

 

Still, she is receiving only scattered reports from area residents finding dead animals, and few reporting more than one or two at a time.

 

One resident did, however, report seeing numerous dead birds near Rattlesnake Island. Shimek said they'll head over that way first thing today to look for the dead waterfowl.

 

E-mail Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

 

{mos_sb_discuss:2}

Upcoming Calendar

12Dec
14Dec
12.14.2024 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Christmas Bird Count
14Dec
12.14.2024 9:00 am - 10:00 am
Wreaths Across America
14Dec
12.14.2024 10:00 am - 1:00 pm
Farmers' Market at the Mercantile
19Dec
12.19.2024 4:00 pm - 6:00 pm
General plan agricultural focus group meeting
21Dec
12.21.2024 10:00 am - 1:00 pm
Farmers' Market at the Mercantile
24Dec
12.24.2024
Christmas Eve
25Dec
12.25.2024
Christmas Day
31Dec
12.31.2024
New Year's Eve
1Jan
01.01.2025
New Year's Day

Mini Calendar

loader

LCNews

Award winning journalism on the shores of Clear Lake. 

 

Newsletter

Enter your email here to make sure you get the daily headlines.

You'll receive one daily headline email and breaking news alerts.
No spam.