Lost Password?
No account yet? Register

Games

Arcade
Sudoku
Murphy: Lessons from a visit to Mexico PDF Print E-mail
Written by Philip Murphy   
Friday, 19 December 2008
A couple of weeks ago I was able to spend a few days south of the border for the first time in over a decade, and it was a sobering experience.


While most of my time was spent in built-up tourista areas, I did get to do a fair amount of driving around and got to see some of the poorer and more rural areas as well, and was surprised by what I observed everywhere I went.


Of course there were the loud-mouth drunk American tourists to keep one's national pride in check, but the thing that was truly humbling as a gringo was what the locals were doing.


Probably the most obvious example was the condition of the roads; even in the most humble neighborhoods the pavement was better than almost ANY street in Lakeport, and nowhere were the roadways as crude as they are in the city of Clearlake.


The reason was apparent everywhere I went, as road construction/repair was taking place all over the place. Mexico has obviously decided that good roads mean safe travels and good jobs for lots of people, and they are investing heavily in this aspect of their infrastructure.


It was also obvious that the building boom bust had not yet affected Mexico, as all sorts of structures were being erected – homes, businesses and government buildings, too. Signs of prosperity were everywhere, and there were no signs of some of our social problems, which had even more impact on me than it did on my last visit many years ago when it was not too uncommon to see children working.


There were no homeless people panhandling or stumbling around drunk in the parks, unlike my hometown of San Francisco, where the crazies, drunks and druggies roam the streets in annoying and sometimes frightening groups with barely any attempts to redirect their behavior.


Then there was the garbage issue, or to be more precise, the lack of it. Poor neighborhood, tourist zone or rural highways were all the same, they were trash-free.


I'm not sure if this is because an army of workers are employed to pick up roadside refuse or if people just don't throw so much stuff out the window of their cars, but whatever the reason for it the lack of misplaced garbage it made me think of the litter-choked ditches and roadsides around here, and how even when they are picked up a week later they're a mess again in some places, I have a hard time just keeping up with my trash problem generated by the one-third of a mile of county road that bisects my property.


Not only were the roadsides trash-free, but everywhere I saw a public garbage can in Mexico it was divided into two sides, organic and non-organic halves. Apparently Mexicans are more concerned with recycling than Americans, and are making the effort to sort all the trash they can into groups that can help keep landfills from getting used and again, keep people employed while preserving natural resources.


So I kept wondering, why can't we do some of these things? Are Americans too dumb or lazy to sort garbage? It does take a couple of seconds to read the signs that tell you what goes where, plus a bit of eye-hand coordination to get it there, can that be beyond us?


Haven't we been playing games by postponing road repairs for too long, and now the problem is so big it seems almost hopeless to try to get caught up?


Should we settle for roads that are unacceptable in third world countries, and continue to spend the nation's wealth on B-2 bombers and wars in far-off places that never threatened us?


If Mexico can keep crazy people off the streets and stop lazy people and drunks from annoying the rest of the citizenry then why can't we?


This isn't how you show leadership, it's time to pull our heads out of the sand folks, unless we want to become another Britain in our lifetimes.


Philip Murphy lives in Finley.


Discuss this article on the forums. (0 posts)

Trackback(0)
Comments (7)Add Comment
How Do They Do It?
written by purplegirl, December 22, 2008
Well, it all sounds nice on the surface but you need to consider that Mexico has less than half the population of the U.S. and if you investigate a little further, you might find that they can do what they do at (quite literally) not at their own expense but at ours. The Mexican government has a great setup. It encourages most of their population to illegally cross our borders, and live off of our government (not their own) through our employment, health and welfare systems. And, then, they are encouraged to send much of this money home to be spent on their economy (not ours). It is a cushy setup for their government (who paves the roads which they have to drive on and deals with the garbage which they have to put out) because out of a population less than half the size of the U.S. they don't have to pay for a good portion of them to receive benefits from the government because they are receiving benefits from OUR government. Add to the pot, Mexico's government has a thriving income (though, most Mexicans don't) as receives quite a bit of money from being one of the hottest spots for U.S. tourism, it doesn't take much to see how they can afford a paved road or two.
where were you?
written by Grace OMalley, December 22, 2008
conditions vary widely, perhaps partly depending on how much money the central government in DF returns to the municipalities.
Through many decades of time spent in Mexico, I've observed women (or their maids)sweeping the streets and sidewalks in front of their houses twice a day. Some towns have daily garbage pickup, others have piles of disposable diapers under signs that say "no basura" -- no garbage-- at the edge of town.
Cleanliness has always been a habit in Mexico. The indigenous people were startled by the lack of it among European invaders.
It pays
written by Raphael, December 22, 2008
to travel outside the US, and outside of the tourist areas-tourist traps once in a while, to learn how the rest of the world lives...
America isn't the center of the universe, there are a lot of interesting things happening in other nations, some of these nations are far ahead of us in certain areas, some are behind.
We could definitively do better, given our resources, if we weren't so spoiled and apathetic (physically overfed and intellectually undernourished?), and if we didn't spent so much money on the war machine.
Like the Roman empire towards the end, we have over-extended ourselves in imperialistic adventures that cannot be sustained, and are crumbling at the core.
excuse me purplegirl...
written by smurf, December 22, 2008
but if you ate food today you need to thank a Mexican, without those brown hands this country would be seeing people kill each other for food in a week-they do over 90% of the work on the farms.

This whole country would grind to a halt without the nurses, farm workers and food processers, janitors and garbage men from south of the border, it's not their fault that WE lure them with jobs.
In Actuality
written by purplegirl, December 23, 2008
In actuality, if you read my post clearly, you would see that I wasn't taking issue with the people (neither living in Mexico nor those living in the U.S.) I was taking issue with their GOVERNMENT and how their government is able to do all these things you speak of.

You seem to think that it is all so peachy keen down there in Mexico and that the Mexican people are so taken care of with their roads, their poor, their homeless... and I was simply pointing out how their government can do it by pushing many of their governmental responsibilities onto us so they can basically pick and choose their responsibilities

If Mexico is so awesome, why are Mexicans willing to risk life and death to come here? You say it is the lure of our jobs but it would seem if it were as great as you describe down there they wouldn't be lured by anything we had to offer. Again, my beef isn't with the people, my beef is with their government which you seem to think (from your article) that "Mexico has obviously decided that good roads mean safe travels and good jobs for lots of people" and that there were "no signs of some of our social problems" when in reality (big reality check) if this (again) were true then the people of Mexico wouldn't be risking life and limb to come here.
Putting This Into Perspective
written by purplegirl, December 23, 2008
After thinking about it for a bit, I realize, my thoughts on this are much like my thoughts on how Native Americans are treated. If you were a foreigner visiting this country, and you visited the Robinson Rancheria and the little subdivision on that land, you would think that Native Americans have it great. On the surface, it seems, they have casinos for built in employment, they have decent housing and a thriving infrastructure, they even have a new recycling center, and there is not a single sign of any social problems (you don't see any drunk or homeless wandering their streets there). But, if you take a closer look, you would see that this isn't really an accurate depiction of their lives it is simply what many of us choose to see with a passing glance. I am simply urging people to look a little deeper before getting euphoric about how wonderful other people have it.
Phil\'s other Mexico
written by Hwy175, December 24, 2008
Phil, I have traveled extensively in Mexico for many years. I very much enjoy the country, and the people. That said, I don't know where you went. Mexico's problems with public litter and apathy by the general public regarding the environment are unparalleled. Years of governing by the horribly corrupt PRI party have contributed to a deteriorated infrastructure where graft or quid pro quo is the only thing that can get your local road repaired, or public utilities brought to your area. The fantasy land that you describe may be a small pocket that has been improved for benefit of the tourist, to quell the guilt that many feel when visiting a developing country. Mexico's government - national, state and local operates in an environment of corruption. It was this system that gave rise to the saying "Show me a poor politician and I'll show you a poor politician."
Phil, while I often disagree with you, this does not mean that I think that you are stupid, or that you are disingenuous. Here, however, I am afraid that you have been hoodwinked. If you saw no homeless, then you can rest assured that the heavy handed cops beat them out of the town, so as not to upset the dollar laden tourists.
Do not look to Mexico for a good example. Look to Mexico to see what happens when things get about 50 times worse than they have ever been in Lake County.
Phil, this faux pas make me embarrassed for you... if you don't know, don't opine.

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
Powered By Page_Cache by Ircmaxell
Generated in 0.96709609031677 Seconds